Nepali Times
Nation
Gap year ripoffs


IRENE PERONI



NAYANTARA GURUNG KAKSHAPATI

MODEL NGO: Past volunteers at German-sponsored Shanti Sewa Griha, a centre for leprosy patients near Pashupatinath have described their experience as "incredibly inspiring".

For some young westerners, Nepal appears the perfect place to combine a few weeks of well-intentioned volunteer work with some of the world's most accessible and dramatic outdoor adventures.

Type 'volunteer+Nepal' into an Internet search engine and there are any number of contacts. Projects in developing countries to occupy young volunteers in their gap years between school and university have become big business and can be expensive. Month-long programs organized through reputable outfits like Volunteer Abroad, i-to-i, or Projects Abroad, can cost more than $2,000.

That is why many students and professionals on a career break are resorting to a much more affordable alternative: surfing the net for small-scale, low-key Nepali NGOs. A few clicks of the mouse bring a plethora of placement offers in all the popular fields: conservation, health care, teaching and orphanages, with prices from as little as $250 a month.

But as these volunteering opportunities have sprung up, so too have scams and sloppily organised operations which are only too happy to take people's money, but haven't given much thought to what they should provide in return.

"I hate it when people come here with the best intentions and get ripped off by some money-minded outfit, be it Nepali or international," says a volunteer social worker who has been living in Kathmandu for several years and prefers to remain anonymous. Many leave feeling cheated and vow never to come back, giving Nepal a bad name.

"I've had people literally cry on my shoulder saying: 'I wanted to do something good but I've been let down and I've lost so much money'," says the social worker.

A typical is a girl from London who had saved up and borrowed money to volunteer. She contacted INFO Nepal, a local NGO, and paid $1,200 per week to teach in an orphanage. When she got here, she complained that the place was filthy, the children were malnourished and mistreated, some were sick, and she had to share a room with a male stranger.

Some volunteering programs are being cleverly advertised abroad. Internship Nepal, a Kathmandu-based NGO which promotes itself through the US National Press Photographers' Association as well as some US photojournalism magazines, promises foreign journalism students work placements with some of the best-regarded Nepali media, all duly listed on its website.

There is a $50 non-refundable deposit and the first month costs $500 full board. It isn't clear that the chairman of the organization is also the head of the host family, and so keeps all the money himself. Some students have joined the program only to find that nothing has been arranged for them ahead of their arrival.

Daniel Sato and Ren? Edde, two American photojournalism students who detailed their Internship Nepal mishaps on their respective blogs, arrived in the summer of 2006. They quickly smelt a rat when they found that the publications they had been assigned to were completely unaware of the program. They subsequently quit after paying $250 for a few days' stay in the NGO chairman's home.

To be sure, there are charity groups that offer genuine volunteer programs from which both Nepalis and foreigners benefit.

Haley Hunt-Brondwin, 19, from Canada, has been here for one month and is quite enthusiastic about her placement at a children's home which she got through VSN (Volunteer Services Nepal). Her program started with a proper training week including language classes, a lot of cultural information and instructions on her daily routine. "Things have been great for me, but I also met volunteers with other NGOs who had a real culture shock-they felt overwhelmed because they had no idea what living and working here would be like."

Emma Rahmin, VSN's Filipino-born founder and executive director, recommends doing an Internet search on the NGO you have picked to make sure there have not been any major complaints about it in the past. "And of course if you can, it is better to join a program once you are already in Nepal," she adds.

WHAT TO LOOK OUT FOR
. Ask the NGO for names and email addresses of their former volunteers.
. Google the NGO you have chosen and check the results carefully.
. Avoid paying your whole fee right upon arrival if you have
any concerns.
. If you can, come to Nepal first and "shop around" to see what
is available.
. Post some feedback on the Internet: it will be useful to future volunteers.


The accidental tourist

Jane Diamond, a 37-year-old subtitler from the UK, is having dinner on a balcony overlooking a bustling Thamel street. She came to Nepal full of good intentions, but is now leaving dissatisfied and irritated. She had planned to work at an organic farm for five weeks but instead ended up spending $1,200 on an unintended holiday. The bad vibes had started before she even got on the plane.

"Ahead of my trip, I kept sending emails to the person in charge of WWOOF Nepal (an NGO promoting organic farming)," Jane says. "I wanted to know where my farm was and what exactly my tasks would be, but each time I got the same reply: 'Don't worry, I will guide you.' When she landed in Kathmandu, she still did not know her destination. She was finally put in touch with a farmer near Pokhara, who in turn passed her on to another farm in the Kalesti Valley, two hours east of the lakeside town.

"When I got there, there was no farm as such," she says. "The would-be farmer took me around meeting local communities, thinking I was an expert in organic farming. I tried to explain that I didn't have those skills. We both ended up feeling quite embarrassed."

Jane quit after a few days. She does not consider herself the victim of a rip-off, but does feel misled and let down.

We contacted WWOOF by email about the allegations and the reply from Faninda Regmi was: 'We are trying to reorganise WWOOF, if you come next year we won't charge you membership fees.I am sorry friend.could you excuse us."


1. alex, Australia
well as you can find INFO has got the connection with other volunteer organisation based on overseas they charge thousand of dollar and send volunteer to Nepal with INFO its like a ripoff ... volunteer doesn't know about that connection. there are lots of organisation that you can choose and provides excellent volunteer service ... in Nepal

2. Martin, Belgium
I volunteered with INFO Nepal, it was quite painful experience, during emailing they told me I was paying 800$ for a month. After I arrived in Nepal, had few days Nepali class and sightseeing with them. They asked me to pay 500$ extra for their orphan home building project. There were no any options to switch my contract off, I paid them then they took me to Langtong that was great village and family. My host family was originally Tibetan and so gorgeous who fed me nice dahl baht. I became good friend of their children, used to play every day. Eventually I found that they are paid 20$ a month, I was so sorry for them. I asked my self where did my 1300$ go? I could not find answers.

3. jange, new nepal
Paying money to volunteer?? What next? Paying money to have a job?

4. Sarah, France
I was wondering there are two VSNs in Nepal which one is the real? I am volunteering in Nepal this fall.

5. Brittany Sears, email
After reading about the problems faced by volunteers in Nepal ('Gap year rip offs', #372) I had to write to you. Having travelled in both Asia and Africa, I was immediately struck by a sense of safety and comfort upon my arrival in Nepal almost one year ago. Though I was supposed to stay only five months, something about the friendly, smiling faces made me stay longer. I taught English, made a library, travelled around the country. Then, I began to work with INFO Nepal that organizes placements for foreign volunteers as Volunteer Coordinator. I had responsibility, freedom, and variety in my work. Then, things went very, very wrong. I arrived at work one morning to an e-mail from two of our volunteers placed in Prabatipur, Chitwan. There had been a horrific sexual harassment incident in the home where they were staying with INFO's host family. What followed was a long saga of misunderstanding between my employers and I over the question of refunding the volunteers who pay 125 euros a week to be in Nepal. The incident opened my eyes and I saw the organization for what it was: a business, a money-making enterprise, disguised as an NGO. Volunteers weren't valued, appreciated or respected. Prior to arrival, the volunteers were promised the moon but once they got here and paid their fees, the attitude changed dramatically. This is only a brief summary of one organization dealing with volunteers. This has resulted in foreigners, myself included, beginning to lose trust in Nepalis. Certainly not all Nepalis are this way, but I have become skeptical. This is a problem for the entire country, and thus should be taken seriously by all Nepalis.

6. Nicky, London
I don't know, heard that also foreigners involve in ripping offs volunteers.

7. Melissa Cain, Toronto, Cannada
I'm sorry to bother you, but I am a bit concerned about a couple of issues that were raised by a previous volunteer ( Overseas Coordinator ) I emailed. It was suggested to me that the money which volunteers pay to INFO is a lot more than the host families receive in rent, and that INFO often do not pay the families on time each month. I don't like to be confrontational about this, but I would be paying a lot of money to your organisation and I would like to feel certain that Info Nepal is a non-profit charity, and that the host families are paid well for housing the volunteers. I 've heard this INFO Nepal is solo organization run by husband and wife? taking lot of profit on pocket rather spending on project.

8. George G, UK
avoid INFO. paying anyone to go volunteer in nepal or anywhere is a scam. if you fall for that you deserve to be cheated.

9. Sarah C,, Australia
Yeah Melissa you've heard very right, INFO is profitable organization run by husband and wife (Asim and Namrata). I think they forgot to put their 2 son;s picture on INFO team list. Bicky - Program Director - have his own VCD NEPAL - Bishal Paudel - volunteer Co-ordinator - run his own volunteer company www.bestvolunteer.org -- Durga Giri - No more working with INFO Nepal - He teaches at Kaskikot School Pokhara. -- Mr. Saroj Shrestha - Chitwan Coordinator - No more working with INFO - he have is own guest house business at Chitwan, organize safari tour. So, how can they be INFO team, if they are not working with INFO???

10. SuGauli, Kathmandu
Badnam nai gareka chan ni yesto organisation le Nepal ma. B/C of this kind of organisation people are afraid to invest on good ones too. INFO is a Parasite organisation who is sucking blood in the name of humanity. Shame on you guys...

11. BBShreshta, Image Academy,Kathmandu
How can I join with you? What we can do for the children for their education development?



  • Most Commented
  • Most Referred
 
LATEST COMMENTS
gorkhemutu on 'Gallery': IF YOU ALL HAVE FAITH, AND YOU ARE BIT RELIGIOUS, THEN YOU SHOULD THINK OF ONE ....
jai maobadi on 'Gallery': Those people, who still think the Gyanendra a hero or a king, are a real douchebag. ....

SPECIAL
Travel Nepal

Madesh Special

himalkhabar.com            Wave            Himal Khabarpatrika

NEPALI TIMES IS A PUBLICATION OF HIMALMEDIA PRIVATE LIMITED | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | SUBSCRIPTION | CONTACT