Nepali Times
MARK ZIMMERMAN
Comment
Not just any doctor


MARK ZIMMERMAN


Across Nepal, when you ask people in a tea shop, office, or out on the road about health care, almost everyone replies: "What we really need in our town is a doctor." What they should actually be saying is: "We really need an MDGP doctor."

Many young people all over the world want to become doctors. Nepal will soon be producing over 1,000 new doctors every year. But what kind of doctors does Nepal really need?

In Nepal a young doctor earns an MBBS degree, and follows that with a 3-5 year post-graduate specialisation to become a surgeon, pediatrician, obstetrician, internist, pathologist or radiologist. Specialised doctors are fine in their field, but aren't very competent outside their area.

MDGP doctors are specialists, but with a difference: they're all-rounders trained to be competent in each of the main medical fields. After a three-year course, they know how to care for children, deliver babies, perform essential operations, take care of sick adults with a variety of medical problems. MDGPs are the frontline primary care doctors in the cities and in the districts they are the life-savers.

General practice (or MDGP) training began at the Institute of Medicine in 1982, and was the country's first post-graduate doctor training. In the last six years, the BP Koirala Institute of Health Sciences and the National Academy of Medical Science (NAMS) have started MDGP training.

Nepal's MDGP program is a leader in South Asia, and even the Christian Medical College of Vellore gets academic accreditation for its GP program from Nepal's Institute of Medicine. Compared to general practice (or family medicine) doctors in the US or UK, Nepal's GP doctors are more skilled in surgical procedures, such as caesarean sections.

Because one MDGP doctors can cover a range of medical areas, they are the most appropriate for district hospitals across Nepal. In late 2007, when there was a hospital crisis in Dadeldhura the Health Ministry promptly transferred two MDGP doctors there. A dusty, old hospital, which was under-used for years, immediately picked up and started doing 40 deliveries and 30 operations a month.

Baglung used be a lonely government hospital that patients ignored, preferring to go to Pokhara for treatment. That was until Tarun Paudel arrived in 1999. This MDGP doctor helped transform Baglung into a model district training hospital where 800 babies are delivered every year and caesarean sections and other operations are regularly conducted.

Two years ago, the Sindhupalchok district hospital in Chautara was severely damaged in a fierce battle. The resident MDGP, Nanda Lal Sikarmi, survived the attack by hiding under a bed all night and stayed on to rebuild the hospital (see: 'Nepal's unsung heroes') and add new services.

In 2000, UNICEF adopted the Panchthar district hospital hoping to provide better care for mothers and children. It worked, and the main reason for the success was the dedicated work of one MDGP, Gunaraj Lohani.

Compare this to government hospitals where MBBS doctors are posted. Most cannot perform operations, conduct difficult deliveries, and they have to learn as they go.

Considering the medical needs of remote communities and the success of MDGP doctors one would expect that there would be hundreds of MDGPs all across the country by now. But there aren't, and the main reason is lack of recognition by the public and by the Health Ministry itself.

For most people in Nepal a doctor is a doctor, they haven't yet learnt what sets an MDGP apart. A community survey in rural Nepal showed that less than one percent of people had any idea what an MDGP doctor was. Only after a town actually has an MDGP come and work there do people realise the difference.

Harder to understand is why the government doesn't yet seem to see the need for MDGPs. The Ministry of Health and Population has a goal of providing emergency delivery services in all 75 districts. Today, while city hospitals regularly conduct lifesaving caesarian sections, less than 20 percent of the district hospitals do. One reason is the lack of MDGP doctors available to do this operation.

Another reason is that the Health Ministry still has no post for MDGPs and they are treated the same as basic MBBS doctors. As a result, fewer doctors want to enter this specialty. Government health services are like a three-legged stool: one leg preventive, one leg promotive, and one leg curative. In Nepal, the first two legs are reasonably strong. It is the third, curative leg of the stool that is weak, and without it patients in rural areas suffer.

Over the years, I have met and become friends with many doctors in Nepal. They range across all specialties and I know excellent doctors in many fields. Many are famous and admired throughout the country. But I have come to see that one real medical hero of Nepal has not yet been recognized: the MDGP doctor.

Mark Zimmerman is Director of the Nick Simons Institute in Kathmandu.


1. Kaji, Kathmandu
Thanks Mark, truly appreciate for enlighting MDGP & MBBS, and their importance in a country like Nepal. Hope our thick headed masters understand this problem.

2. Dr. Glenn Mitrasing, Amsterdam
Touché dear Collegae; I hope that the doctors can be stimulated to work in the remote areas by giving the attractive salaries too. I remember that a Scottish Organization was spending very much money to get a Scott GP working in the far West as the Nepalese doctors refused to work there for the low salary. Paisa always matters

3. Jaspure, Edinburgh
Multi-tier health system exists in Nepal. The rich ones (or those in a position to abuse authority to make govt spend for their healthcare) go to Bangkok or private hospitals in India. The so called 'middle class' go expensive clinics and 'nursing homes' in Kathmandu. The less privileged ones queue up at government and teaching hospitals in Kathmandu and other big cities. The poor go to local health centres in villages and district hospitals of majority of the country. And finally, there are many who do not have access to any kind of healthcare system whatsoever. MDGPs can play a major leadership role at district level spearheading the tackle against majority of disease conditions. However, let us not forget that embedded within the vision of a 21st century healthcare delivery is the ever-growing need for specialists. Primary care at the health post level; complicated cases to MDGPs at district level; selected cases to zonal hospitals for specialist care; and finally Kathmandu, Dharan, Bharatpur, etc for highly specialised care, e.g. neurosurgery, cardiothoracic surgery, transplant surgery, interventional radiology, etc. For conditions needing long-term or life-long follow up, the continuity of care chain goes backward following the referral chain. Laboratory and imaging services follow the level of care anticipated. For smooth referral, excellent telecommunication and information infrastructure, ambulances, including air ambulances

4. Jaspure, Edinburgh
(CONTINUED FROM ABOVE) including air ambulances

5. Jaspure, Edinburgh
(CONTINUED FROM ABOVE) including air ambulances.... Let me stop dreaming. But let us keep the hope alive. We will reach there one day. For the moment, MDGPs jindabad !!!

6. Nirmal, Modern Nepal
I think the lack of medical doctors in general practices is a global problem.Europe and United States have too,and they contract south and latin american doctors during summer.But who will care their respective countries then?Well,we need these specific Doctors everywhere.May be the scale of necessity could vary from one country to another,the problem is not of one particular nation.So,the policy should be globally drawn amongst all to benefit all.Let's see if these allies from West are interested to make alliances for this great cause rather to destroy the Universe by their nonsense nuclear empowerment.Anyway Sir thanks a lot for discovering the matter.it seems that only western people can identify what we need.Where is the Ministry Of health and what's he doing?

7. Sharon, Peterborough, Canada
Yes, a global problem. In Canada we have the widely acclaimed "Universal Free Healthcare". But in this town of 70,000, 1/3 of the population have no GP, the Women's Health Clinic won't do a PAP test unless a woman is ranked as "high risk", and there is something of an underground network slipping bits of paper with phone numbers with leads on where one might find a nurse practitioner to take a sick infant to, or where one can get a mammogram without a doctor referral. On the other hand, we by and large do have the real conditions for overall health: adequate shelter, food, and clean water to drink. And despite our own political infighting, we have the political structures to ensure this for most. MDGPs (and even lots of health post peons, who I recall did a lot of useful medical work) are fine, but far deeper problems need to be worked out too.

8. Dipak Gurung, Cardiff
Sharon is right, Nepal's health care must focus on preventive since most diseases are infections. Of course there are complicated pregnancies and other surgical procedures where MDGPs would be very useful. and like Jaspure says, it has to be multi-tiered so that complicated procedures are referred to specialist hospitals.

9. Madi, Lagankhel
Respected Dr. Mark, I agree with your dream that Nepal needs more GPs for uplifting its healthcare status. It is however true taht young doctors are not opting for it, the reason is not only financial. Most don't want to go to rural place esp. in government service, where all they get is "forgotten". I don't believe that all doctors run after money. If you give them a clear path for the better future careers I m sure more ll opt for MDGP.

Post a comment


Name

Address

Code (Please type the code below.)

Reload code

Comment (Words limit: )



 
LATEST COMMENTS
John on Remarkable peace: Mr. Martin, it's very unfortunate that foreigner's like you constantly try and impose Western form of ....
watch on 'Gallery': ABC tv/radio = Maoist propaganda machine. ....

SPECIAL
Travel Nepal

Madesh Special

LATEST ISSUE
416
ISSUE NO #416
(05 SEPT 2008 - 11 SEPT 2008)

himalkhabar.com            Wave            Himal Khabarpatrika

NEPALI TIMES IS A PUBLICATION OF HIMALMEDIA PRIVATE LIMITED | ABOUT US | ADVERTISE | SUBSCRIPTION | CONTACT